top of page

Build or buy infrastructure?

We guide your team through the critical "build vs. buy" decision for key infrastructure components. This is a pivotal strategic choice, not just a technical one, that impacts everything from your budget and team focus to your long-term competitive advantage. Our goal is to provide a clear, data-driven framework to ensure the chosen path is sustainable and aligned with your core business objectives.

Business Stages

The "build vs. buy" calculation changes dramatically based on a company's maturity. For startups and growth-phase companies, the scale is heavily tipped towards "buy." The priority is speed to market, conserving capital, and focusing limited engineering talent on the core product, not on reinventing commodity infrastructure. Off-the-shelf SaaS and cloud platforms are the default choice for agility. For a mature business, the decision becomes far more nuanced. With greater capital and deeper engineering resources, building becomes a viable option. The conversation shifts to long-term TCO, the need for deep customization, stringent security controls, and the potential to create a proprietary asset that provides a competitive moat.

Start-Up

Laying the groundwork and bringing your vision to life.

Launch

Introducing your business to the market and gaining initial traction.

Growth

Scaling your operations and expanding your customer base.

Plateau

Reaching a period of stability and consistent performance.

Mature

Optimizing operations and maximizing profitability.

Acquisition/Expansion

Leveraging success for further growth through acquisition and expansion.

Exit

Transitioning ownership or closing the business.

Compelling Event

The "build vs. buy" debate is often forced by a compelling event. The "bought" solution may start to creak under the strain of scale, or its per-user pricing model becomes prohibitively expensive. A critical need for customization to launch a new flagship service might be impossible with a rigid, off-the-shelf tool. A new, complex compliance or security requirement could expose the limitations of a vendor's platform. Conversely, a strategic analysis might reveal that the ever-increasing subscription fees for a dozen different tools could be better invested in building a single, integrated platform that is cheaper to own in the long run.

Declining Growth

Persistent underperformance despite consistent effort.

New Service Launch

Change or addition to a service to respond to customer preference or market conditions.

Entering New Market

Analyzing industry trends and customer insights for expansion.

Competitive Pressure

Emerging competitors or changing customer preferences.

Sales Expansion

Sales management for high performance growth and efficient customer targetting.

Market Disruption

 Inability to capitalize on new trends or technologies.

Elements of a Strategic Plan

A plan to address the "build vs. buy" question is fundamentally a strategic cost-benefit analysis framework. It begins by rigorously defining the business problem the infrastructure must solve, distinguishing between core competencies and commodity functions. The plan requires a comprehensive Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) model for both paths, looking at a 5-10 year horizon and including all costs: subscriptions, development, staffing, maintenance, and opportunity cost. It mandates a thorough capability audit (do we have the talent to build and maintain this?) and a dual-path risk assessment (e.g., vendor lock-in vs. project failure). The final output is a clear, defensible recommendation and a high-level roadmap for the chosen path.

Foundational Assessment:

Begin by understanding your current position and the landscape you operate in.

Service Development & Enhancement

Enhance your core offerings and innovate to meet evolving customer needs.

Sales & Marketing Strategies, GTM

Reach the right customers with the right message at the right time.

Go-to-Market Planning

Plan your launch carefully to ensure a smooth and successful market entry.

Technology Integration & Differentiation

Harness the power of technology to enhance your services and streamline operations.

Employee Empowerment & Development

Invest in your people to ensure they are equipped to support your growth strategy.

Monitoring & Evaluation

Track your progress, adapt to change, and continuously improve your approach.

What does it look like?

Build vs. Buy: A Framework for Strategic Decision-Making

This framework provides a structured process to move beyond gut feelings and make a data-driven decision on whether to build or buy key infrastructure.

​

1. Foundational Assessment: Core Competency Analysis

Before evaluating any solution, define the problem in the context of your business strategy.

  • Strategic Importance: Is this infrastructure a commodity function (like email or payroll) or is it a core part of your unique value proposition?

  • Competitive Differentiation: Could a custom-built solution create a significant, defensible competitive advantage in the market?

  • Problem Definition: Clearly articulate the business problem you are trying to solve, independent of any specific technology or solution.

 

2. Dual-Path Requirement Definition: Defining Needs for Both Scenarios

Translate your business problem into specific requirements for both building and buying.

  • "Buy" Requirements: Define the functional, technical, security, and integration requirements you would need from a third-party vendor.

  • "Build" Requirements: Define the scope, features, performance, and scalability requirements for an in-house development project.

  • Future Needs: Project how these requirements might evolve over the next 3-5 years. Will your needs diverge from what standard vendors offer?

 

3. Market Scan & Internal Audit: Sizing Up Options

Simultaneously explore the external market and your internal capabilities.

  • Vendor Landscape (The "Buy" Path): Research and identify the top 2-3 vendors that could meet your requirements. Conduct initial demos and pricing inquiries.

  • Internal Capability Audit (The "Build" Path): Honestly assess your team's skills, experience, and bandwidth. Do you have the necessary talent to not only build but also maintain and scale this infrastructure?

  • Resource Gap Analysis: For the "build" path, what additional talent would you need to hire? For the "buy" path, what internal resources are needed for implementation and management?

 

4. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) Modelling: The Full Financial Picture

Create a comprehensive, long-term financial model for both options. Don't just look at the sticker price.

  • "Buy" TCO: Include subscription/licensing fees, implementation/setup costs, training, customization, and ongoing internal management costs.

  • "Build" TCO: Include all development costs (salaries, tools), infrastructure hosting costs, ongoing maintenance and support staff, and the opportunity cost of pulling developers off other projects.

  • 5-Year Projection: Model the TCO for both paths over at least a 5-year horizon to account for scaling costs, vendor price increases, and maintenance overhead.

 

5. Risk Assessment: What Could Go Wrong?

Identify and evaluate the unique risks associated with each path.

  • "Buy" Risks: Vendor lock-in, unexpected price hikes, the vendor going out of business, the vendor's roadmap not aligning with your future needs, data security issues.

  • "Build" Risks: Project delays and cost overruns, failure to deliver on requirements, key personnel leaving, creating a technical debt burden, diverting focus from core product innovation.

  • Mitigation Plan: For the top risks on both paths, outline potential mitigation strategies.

 

6. Strategic & Qualitative Analysis: Beyond the Numbers

Consider the non-financial factors that will impact your business.

  • Speed to Market: How quickly can you solve the business problem with each option?

  • Flexibility & Control: How much control and ability to customize do you need? How important is it to control your own destiny and roadmap?

  • Focus & Opportunity Cost: Does building this infrastructure distract your team from your primary mission, or does it enhance it?

 

7. Decision & Roadmap: Making the Call and Planning the Path

Use a structured approach to make the final decision and outline the next steps.

  • Decision Matrix: Use a scorecard to rank the build vs. buy options against your key criteria (e.g., TCO, strategic alignment, risk, speed to market).

  • Final Recommendation: Formulate a clear, data-backed recommendation for one path over the other.

  • High-Level Roadmap: Whichever path is chosen, outline the immediate next steps, key milestones, and required resources to begin execution.

bottom of page